Shares In BVI Business Companies: Avoiding A Succession Problem

Failure to put appropriate succession plans in place may result in unanticipated or undesired outcomes that will inevitably involve delay and increased cost in dealing with the shares after death. This, in turn, may have significant and adverse consequences for the commercial life of the company which effectively may be put on hold. The adverse consequences will be exacerbated if the shareholder in question is also the company’s sole director and no reserve director has been nominated – a situation that occurs with surprising frequency – since in such circumstances, the assistance of the BVI Court will be required to break the management impasse.

It is therefore very important that careful thought is given to succession planning in relation to BVI shares where they are or will be registered in the name of an individual. Succession planning may take the form of a ‘BVI Will’ dealing exclusively with the BVI company shares, or the establishment of a BVI trust, or issuing different classes of shares in the BVI company.

BVI Wills

A BVI Will may be the simplest and most appropriate form of succession planning where, at least, the individual is not subject to ‘forced heirship’ rules. It may also be the most appropriate vehicle for individuals who are subject to such rules, but where there is no desire to make any provisions inconsistent with them.

In either case, a BVI Will may be advisable because a foreign representative of the deceased’s worldwide estate (or a person beneficially entitled to it under foreign law) will have no title under BVI law to deal with BVI situated assets. Shares in a BVI business company are, for this purpose, treated as BVI situated under BVI law. Accordingly, even a validly appointed foreign representative of a deceased person’s estate will have to make application to the BVI Court for a grant of representation before there can be any lawful dealing with the BVI company shares. It is, however, significantly less costly and quicker for the executor of a BVI Will that deals with the BVI company shares to obtain a grant of probate of that will in the BVI.

It is extremely important to obtain legal advice with regard to drafting a BVI Will. Matters can become complicated where the deceased person has executed several wills, all governed by the laws of different jurisdictions. It is important to ensure that one will does not inadvertently revoke another, or purport to deal with the same property as another will but in a different manner.    

Grant Of Probate Procedure

In order to obtain a BVI grant of probate, a formal application is made to the Court by the executors appointed under the terms of the BVI Will. It may take the Court at least four to six months to process the application. However, from the date of the shareholder’s death until the grant of probate has been issued by the BVI Court, the BVI shares are effectively paralysed as no one can vote, transfer or sell them, or give valid receipt for any dividends.  

Reserve Director

It is common for an individual to be sole shareholder and sole director of a BVI company. Upon such an individual’s death, there will be no director authorised to update the shareholder register or pass a shareholder resolution to appoint a new replacement director. However, it is possible to avoid this problem by nominating a ‘reserve director’ whose appointment is effective upon the death of the sole director. 

BVI Trusts

Where the owner of BVI shares is subject to forced heirship rules and wishes to make provision for the shares’ devolution which differs from that of the jurisdiction of his domicile at death, a BVI Will is likely to be an inappropriate succession planning tool. This is because, in respect of shares in a BVI business company (which are classified as movable rather than immovable property for succession purposes), BVI law treats the law of the jurisdiction of domicile at death as the law governing succession to movable property. If the provisions of a BVI Will contravene the law applicable to the testator’s domicile at death, they will not have effect. 

Accordingly, a more robust structure is needed, and in many cases a BVI trust will meet that need since no transfer of property into a BVI trust may be set aside by the BVI Court on the ground that the transfer defeats heirship rights – or rights conferred on a person by reason of a personal relationship, including marriage or former marriage – under foreign law. It may also be the case that a timely lifetime transfer into trust may have beneficial estate or inheritance tax consequences which are jurisdiction specific, and on which separate onshore advice needs to be taken. 

It is also possible for a settlor who transfers his BVI company shares into a BVI trust, to reserve certain powers relating to the administration of the trust, such as the power to amend or revoke the trust, or the right to receive dividends, and to direct the trustee to make certain investments of the company’s property, ie the trust’s assets.

A BVI trust has the advantage over a BVI Will in that the settlor may retain some control and benefit from the BVI shares during his lifetime. Furthermore, a BVI trust provides longer term estate planning as the BVI company shares may remain in trust long after the settlor’s death. Also, should the settlor become incapacitated and unable to deal with his business and affairs, the terms of the trust instrument may deal with such an event. A BVI trust has the added advantage that any dealings with the BVI company shares will not be paralysed upon the settlor’s death or incapacity, and there will be no issue of delay whilst an application for probate or other court procedures are pursued in respect of the settlor’s death or ill health.  

VISTA Trusts: Retaining A Degree Of Control

The Virgin Islands Special Trusts Act, 2003 (as amended) (VISTA) provides for the creation of a type of BVI statutory trust known as the VISTA trust. VISTA is an innovative trust specifically designed to hold shares in a BVI incorporated company under which the trustee may be disengaged from management responsibility, notwithstanding that his trust shareholding gives him a controlling interest in the company, in relation to the company’s affairs. It therefore allows the company and its business to be retained and run as its directors see fit.

The effect of VISTA is to remove the trustee’s duty to monitor and intervene in the conduct of the directors and the management of the trust’s underlying BVI company. 

VISTA trusts may continue indefinitely, and the regime can apply to discretionary trusts, fixed interest trusts, charitable, or purpose trusts, subject to satisfying the statutory criteria.   

At least one of the trustees of a VISTA trust must be a BVI company licensed under the BVI’s Banks and Trust Companies Act, or a BVI private trust company. Individuals or non-BVI companies may be co-trustees of VISTA trusts. The features of a VISTA trust, which have been highlighted above, are likely to give comfort to settlors who put their BVI company shares into trust, that a significant amount of control over any disposition may still lawfully be retained by them under BVI law.

Classes Of Shares   

As an alternative to the above options, the individual shareholder of a BVI company may wish to make provision for his or her heirs by way of issuing different classes of shares. For example, the parent(s) hold class A economic voting shares, with the heirs holding class B non-voting shares, and upon the parent’s death, his or her class A shares are automatically cancelled and the heirs’ class B shares are automatically converted into class A voting shares. There is therefore no requirement to apply for a grant of probate. The implementation of shareholder agreements are often required, which may suit some clients and their families, but not all. It depends on the family dynamics, expectations, and activities of the company. It should also be noted that BVI shares (voting and non-voting) may not be held by a minor.

A simple option would also be for the BVI shares to be held by, for example, the parents as ‘joint tenants’ whereby rights of survivorship apply. Thus, upon the death of one parent, the shares automatically pass to the surviving co-owning spouse, which avoids the need to apply for a grant of probate.  

In the vast majority of cases, one or other of the succession planning tools discussed above may be appropriate where shares in a BVI business company are held by an individual. The sensible time to address such questions is at the point of incorporation of the BVI company, but failure to address them during the lifetime of the shareholder may risk frustrating the very aims sought to be achieved by incorporating in the BVI to begin with.

Robert Lindley
Robert is a Partner and Head of Conyers’ Cayman & BVI Private Client and Trust practice, specialising in wealth structuring, estate planning and probate matters, in addition to advising clients in the digital assets and crypto space. Robert also has significant experience in trust and estate litigation, and other cross-border private client disputes. He has been recognised in the recent (and previous) editions of Chambers (HNW) and Legal 500 directories.